Remnants in Red

“Bhreatunnach o’n Talla Dheirg
Uaisle `shliochd Albann do shloinne”
Britons from the Red Hall
the noblest race in Scotland
Good luck sifting among the grains for the kernel of truth in any quest for the origin of the Campbell Clan of Scotland. Root and branch - it is a very tangled tree. My grandmother - Ida Annie - was born Campbell and proud.
Rather than provide answers all we can really do is point the way. Unfortunately, Neil MacEwan, last of the hereditary bards and sennachies to the Campbell Chiefs died in 1650 but “never forget” is the rule of thumb. It may be wondered today what difference would there have been if the tanistry system remained in place. Who would be a member of the “derbhfine” - the inner family? What if descent was measured through the female line?

In simplest terms the Campbell Clan represents an amalgam of the Irish-Scoti and Brythonic/Pict bloodlines. The clan has always had links to the West of Scotland - particularly Strathclyde, Lennox and, of course, Argyll. Of particular significance is “Dunadh an Talla Dheirg” - the Fortress of the Red Hall located at Dùn Breatainn (Fort of the Brythons now known as Dumbarton) in the ancient kingdom of Ystrad Clud (Strathclyde).

Mention should also be made of the elusive, Epidii (now presumed to be a P-Celtic people). Several commentators have asserted that their name implies a worship of the goddess Epona (Rhiannon/Rigantona - Great Queen). The area they are presumed to have controlled later became the heartland of the kingdom of Dál Riata. At its center is Dunadd (the fort on the Add) near Kilmartin. At one time an island, it now lies inland near the River Add. This site later became a seat of the kings of Dál Riata. It is known for its unique stone carvings below the upper enclosure and is remembered in legend as the first location of Stone of Scone. On the same flat outcrop of rock is an incised boar and an inscription in the ogham script.
Many accounts of the origins of the Campbells derive from the manuscript histories compiled by the Neil MacEwan or by Alexander Colvin in the 17th century. These were used as the chief reference by Alexander Campbell in his history of the Campbells of Craignish in about 1720. This history also mentions another 17th century writer of a Campbell genealogy called Robert Duncanson of Campbeltown. Duncanson’s version was titled “Ane Accompt of the Genealogie of the Campbells”. More recently William Forbes Skene (7 June 1809– 29 August 1892) in “Celtic Scotland, a History of Ancient Alban” bases his views on three documents: the early genealogical Scottish clans known as “MS 1467“, the “Kilbride MS c.1550″ edited in “Collecteana de Rebus Albanicis” in 1847 but now lost, and the Campbell pedigree given by the 17th century Irish genealogist Duald MacFirbis (1585-1670) drawing on earlier sources.
Finally the last word in Campbell history is really that of William David Hamilton Sellar (born 1940). Sellar has published on the Lordship of the Isles and on the origins of many Highland families, including the Campbells. He has been a Member of the Ancient Monuments Board for Scotland and Vice-President of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. He has also served on the Council of the Scottish Genealogy Society and the Heraldry Society of Scotland. In 2008, he was appointed Lord Lyon King of Arms - head of Lyon Court with responsibility for overseeing state ceremonial in Scotland and for confirming pedigrees and claims.
Sellar’s investigation into the origins of Clan Campbell - “The Earliest Campbells - Norman, Briton or Gael?” published in Scottish Studies (1973) is the current touchstone. It is basically his lead which is followed by Alastair Campbell in his tour-de-force “A History of Clan Campbell” (2000). Sellar concludes that the original tradition of the Campbell’s derived them quite clearly from British stock. In doing so he largely reaffirms the work of Dr. Alexander MacBain (1855-1907) who wrote: “If the Campbells did not originally belong to Argyle, we must go no further than Dumbartonshire for their habitat. The old genealogies trace them back to the British … a tradition which may indicate that the Campbells originally lived on the borderland of the Strathclyde Briton and the Gael…” Also illuminating are the works of Kenneth Hurlstone Jackson (1909 - 1991) who specialised in the Brythonic languages.

It is safe to say that of all the mythology surrounding the origins of Clan Campbell the Norman strand is the one that can be viewed as a “red herring” - a political ploy rather than a serious claim to continental heritage. It is based mostly around the notion that the name Campbell derives from the French “de Campo Bello” (the beautiful plain) but most scholars believe that its more likely that the name Campbell comes from two Gaelic words “cam” (twisted) and “beul” (mouth). Besides the “p” wasn’t added until the late 15th century. Skene also repudiated the “de Campo Bello” story, saying that there was no early authority whatsoever for it.
At the time of Robert the Bruce they were already holders of land in Argyll, Clackmannanshire, Dumbartonshire and Ayrshire, and allied by marriage to the Earls of Carrick. Gille Escoib or Gilleasbaig of Menstrie is the earliest member of the Campbell family listed by contemporary sources. The name Gille Escoib is often rendered as “Archibald” or “Gillespie” in English. Gilleasbaig’s first historical appearance dates to 1263, when he appeared in a charter of King Alexander III of Scotland. Gilleasbaig was the father of Cailean Mór Caimbeul, also known as Sir Colin Campbell (knighted in 1280 and killed at the “Red Ford” in 1296) probably by marriage to the Carrick noblewoman, Afraig (Efferic). The later Earls and Dukes of Argyll all claim descent from him calling themselves “Mac Cailein Mór”, descendants of “Colin the Great”. Afraig, was a daughter of Cailean mac Dhonnchaidh, the brother of Niall, Earl of Carrick. This means that Cailean himself was the cousin of the future king, Robert I of Scotland, which explains why the Campbells were so attached to the Bruce cause during the Wars of Scottish Independence.

It is generally accepted that Gille Escoib’s grandfather or great-grandfather was Duine Mor/the Great (who himself, was either the father or grandfather of Dugald, the first Campbell to use the name). Sir Thomas Innes of Learney (1893-1971), also Lord Lyon, gives Diarmid O’Duibne as the generally accepted founder of the clan, with the heiress Eva (daughter of Paul “Insporran/an Sparain” O’Duibne) marrying the first Campbell, to whom she conferred the chiefship of the tribe and lordship of Lochawe. In the charter granted in 1369 by David II to Gillespic (Archibald) Campbell he is granted various lands “with all the liberties of the said land as freely as Duncan M’Duine, progenitor of the said Archibald Campbell did enjoy in the barony of Lochow or any other lands belonging to him” (Hist. MSS Comm: 4.477). The heraldic carving over the door of Carnasserie Castle near Kilmartin, built in the 1560s reads “Dia le ua nDhuibne” - “God be with the O’Duibne”.
That is why the Campbells - through the blood of Eva O’Duibne are known as Siol Dhiarmaid, “The Seed of Diarmid” - descended from the legendary folk hero Diarmid O’Duibne himself.
One of the most famous stories in the Fenian cycle is “The Pursuit of Diarmid and Grainne”. In this story, Grainne is overpowered by the supernatural love power of Diarmid, and forces him to elope with her by placing him under geis (magical obligation). Finn pursues them but they escape and raise a family. Eventually Finn pardons them and they return. But Finn’s forgiveness was not genuine, and at a great boar hunt he engineers the death of Diarmid, whose death, it was prophesied, would be due to such an animal. So it fell out, according to the tale. Either the boar kills Diarmid outright or he is commanded by Finn to measure its length along its spine after it has fallen. Diarmid is bare-foot and the stiff hairs of the boar’s hide penetrate and infect his foot so that he dies of poisoning.


































































